Return and Complaint Management Software: Which One to Choose to Increase Customer Satisfaction
There is no single returns and warranty claims tool that fits every store. Three things decide the choice: how many sales channels you sell on, how many requests you get a month, and whether warranty claims are a separate process for you. With a few returns a month, the module built into your store platform is enough. With dozens of requests, dedicated returns software pays off even on one sales channel, and if you sell in your own store and on a marketplace, it also brings everything into one place.
Below you will find three types of solutions, eight questions to ask before you choose, and a test you can run in a week before you pay for the first month.
This is a guide to choosing a tool. If you first want to understand what such a tool is and what it does, start with the returns management system and warranty claims management system pages. We describe the two processes separately, because different deadlines apply.
Before you compare: three facts about your store
Most poor choices come from comparing feature lists before the store has worked out what it needs. Write down three things:
- Sales channels. Your own store, marketplaces, an order management system (OMS). Each channel has its own return path, so the more channels you have, the more you gain from one place for all requests.
- Requests per month, returns and warranty claims separately. A few cases fit in an inbox. At a few dozen, cases start getting lost between email, the carrier’s panel and the warehouse.
- Who handles them. One person who “takes care of it”, or several, including the warehouse? The more people, the more it matters that everyone sees the same state of each case.
Three types of solutions
| Module in your store platform | Returns in your order management system (OMS) | Dedicated returns and warranty claims software | |
|---|---|---|---|
| For whom | one store, a few returns a month | a store already running orders in an OMS | dozens of requests or more, from one channel or several |
| Strength | available right away, usually at no extra cost | returns next to orders and stock levels | one place for requests from every channel, separate paths for returns and warranty claims |
| Where it ends | sees only orders from that one platform | the customer form and warranty claim handling depend on the system and need checking | another subscription and another tool for the team to learn |
These types are not exclusive. Dedicated returns software often works alongside an OMS: the request, customer contact and parcel receiving happen in it, while orders and stock stay where they were. You do not need to change your store platform or OMS to add returns software. Just check that it integrates with what you use. Our list is on the integrations page.
Eight questions to ask about any returns software
1. Does it collect requests from all my sales channels?
This question rules out the most candidates. A tool that sees only your store, or only one marketplace, leaves you two places to watch and two histories of the same case. Ask about marketplace-specific steps too. In RetJet, for example, an Allegro return is refunded and the Allegro commission refund request is submitted from the request itself, without switching to the Allegro panel. More: Allegro returns management and returns from several online stores in one place.
2. Does it handle warranty claims differently from returns?
A return and a warranty claim look similar, but the law treats them differently. Under EU rules, a consumer has 14 days to withdraw from an online purchase, and the seller must refund within 14 days of being informed, though it may withhold the refund until it receives the goods or proof that they were sent. A warranty claim follows the rules on goods not conforming to the contract and often has several stages: inspection, decision, repair or replacement. Deadlines for the seller’s response differ between countries; in Poland, for example, the seller has 14 days to respond to a consumer’s claim.
Software that puts both into one queue hides the most important deadline. Ask whether warranty claims have their own form with a fault description and photos, their own statuses, and a visible response deadline.
3. What do I know about a parcel before it reaches the warehouse?
Some return parcels arrive without any request. The customer sends the item back and asks about the refund by email a few days later. The warehouse gets a parcel nobody expected.
Ask whether the software tracks return shipments and shows what is on its way. In RetJet, parcels sent through the carrier return services we integrate with are visible automatically, even without a request. See monitoring return and warranty claim shipments.
4. How does warehouse receiving work?
This is where the most time goes: someone opens a parcel and searches for the order it belongs to. Ask whether scanning the label is enough for the software to match the parcel to its case, and what happens to a parcel without a label.
In RetJet, a label scan finds the request, and batch mode lets you scan parcels one after another. Parcels without a request can still be worked with in the shipment list until someone identifies them. See identifying parcels by their label.
5. Does the customer need an account or a printer?
Every extra step for the customer means more “how do I send this back?” emails and more parcels sent without a request. A good form works without a login, on your store’s domain, and the parcel can be sent with a code at a parcel locker or pickup point, without a printer. The easiest check is to do it yourself: submit a return on your phone and count the steps. More: returns without printing.
6. How much work does setup take?
Ask specifically: do you need a developer, does the software import your whole order database, and how long does launch take? Continuous synchronisation of all orders means more configuration and more data outside your store.
RetJet fetches order data only when the customer submits a request. Without importing a database, setup usually takes under 10 minutes and needs no developer. How it works: lightweight integration without importing orders.
7. Does it have a right-of-withdrawal function?
EU Directive 2023/2673 requires that consumers can withdraw from an online contract through the same interface they bought in, using a function labelled along the lines of “withdraw from contract here” followed by a confirmation step. The rules apply from 19 June 2026 in member states that have transposed the directive; check the status in each country you sell to.
If you sell to several EU countries, ask whether the software has this function ready. RetJet has it built in: right-of-withdrawal button.
8. What will I see in the data after three months?
Returns software collects information you will not find anywhere else: which products come back, for what reason and how long one case takes. Ask whether customers choose the return reason from a list, because only then can it be counted, and whether reports show reasons by product.
The one-week test: try the software on your own orders
A demo shows the software at its best. A trial shows how it works for you. Over one week, go through these steps on a real or test order:
- Submit a return as a customer, on your phone, without logging in. Count the steps.
- Submit a warranty claim with a photo and a fault description. Check that it goes down a different path from a return and that the deadline is visible.
- Send a return parcel without printing a label.
- Receive one parcel with a label and one without a request in the warehouse. See what the software does with each.
- Submit a request from a second channel, such as a marketplace, and check that it lands in the same view.
- Reply to the customer from the request and check that the conversation stays with the case.
- Close the case and check that the customer was informed without a hand-written email.
If a step needs a workaround or a support ticket, you know where the software ends. The full sequence of a case from request to settlement is in the RMA procedure step by step.
When RetJet fits, and when it does not
This guide is written by the maker of one such tool, so plainly: RetJet is RMA software for online stores: it collects returns and warranty claims from every connected sales channel in one dashboard, from the customer’s form to warehouse receiving.
RetJet fits if you already get dozens of requests a month, have no IT department, and want to handle returns and warranty claims in one place but on separate paths. One sales channel is enough; if you sell on several, such as your own store and a marketplace, requests from all of them land in the same view.
If you use free modules for your store platform, check whether their author keeps them updated and whether they still work after a platform update. A module embedded in the platform depends on its version, and when nobody maintains it, the failure shows up only when customers cannot submit a return. RetJet connects to your store through an API rather than code embedded in the platform.
RetJet does not fit companies with their own IT team building a system from scratch, or sellers of digital services with no parcels to send back.
You can try RetJet on the free plan: 25 requests a month, no card required.
FAQ
Which returns software should a small store choose?
With a few returns a month, start with the module built into your store platform. Dedicated software makes sense at a few dozen requests, even on one sales channel, or when more than one person handles them. A second sales channel, such as a marketplace next to your store, widens the gap but is not a requirement.
Can one tool handle both returns and warranty claims?
Yes, and it is usually more convenient than two tools, as long as it keeps them on separate paths. A warranty claim has different deadlines and a different course from a return.
Does returns software need a “withdraw from contract” button?
Directive 2023/2673 requires a withdrawal function in the interface where the customer bought. It applies in EU member states that have transposed it, from 19 June 2026. If you sell to customers in the EU, check the status in each country.
How long does it take to set up returns software?
It depends on whether the software imports your whole order database and whether it needs a developer. RetJet fetches order data only when a request is submitted, so you can usually set it up yourself in under 10 minutes.
Do I need to change my store platform or OMS?
No. Returns software works alongside your store platform and order system and connects to them through integrations. The full list of RetJet integrations is on the integrations page.